# What happens if I don’t get a Phase 1 ESA?

- Link: https://moran.rocks/what-happens-if-i-dont-get-a-phase-1-esa/
- Published: 2024-02-15T17:39:11-05:00
- Author: Nicholas Moran

If you don’t get a Phase I environmental assessment before purchasing a property,
there are a few key risks:

 1. You may unknowingly buy contaminated property. Without an assessment, you likely
    won’t know if past land uses like industry, gas stations, dry cleaners etc. have
    contaminated the site with hazardous substances.
 2. You may lose the ability to use the innocent landowner defense under CERCLA if 
    contamination is later discovered. Without conducting “all appropriate inquiry”
    including a Phase 1 assessment first, you likely wouldn’t qualify for the innocent
    landowner defense to avoid cleanup liability.
 3. You could become liable for very costly environmental cleanup. Under CERCLA, current
    landowners can be held responsible for cleaning up pollution on their sites, even
    if the contamination occurred decades ago by previous owners. The costs can reach
    hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars in some cases.
 4. Contamination could impact development plans for the site. If undetected pollution
    is severe enough, it may be impossible to build on areas of the property without
    first conducting a cleanup.
 5. You may have difficulty selling the property in the future if buyers discover contamination.
    Pollution issues must be disclosed, which can severely impact property value, financeability,
    and overall marketability until cleaned up.

In summary, skipping a Phase I assessment opens you up to massive potential legal,
financial, health, and planning risks from pre-existing contamination that could
remain hidden on site. Conducting a Phase I is crucial due diligence.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is a Phase I ESA legally required in Florida?

There is no blanket state requirement for all sales, but federal all appropriate
inquiry applies to many commercial transactions, and a compliant Phase I is the 
standard way to demonstrate you met it. Some Florida counties and lenders impose
their own requirements.

### What is the risk of buying a contaminated site without an assessment?

As owner, you may be liable for cleanup costs under CERCLA unless you qualify for
an innocent landowner defense, which requires a compliant Phase I before closing.
Past operators, arrangers or transporters may be unreachable or insolvent.

### Can I lower my risk without a full Phase I ESA?

At minimum, order federal and state database searches for the site and adjoining
properties. It is a useful screen, but it does not satisfy all appropriate inquiry
and is not a substitute for a compliant assessment.

Related: [Phase I ESA services](https://moran.rocks/phase-i-environmental-site-assessment/)·
[Phase II ESA](https://moran.rocks/phase-2-environmental-site-assessment/) · [request a quote](https://moran.rocks/contact-form/)